Loading edition…
Growing Up the Eldest: The Unspoken Contract

Growing Up the Eldest: The Unspoken Contract

Nobody explains the contract. But somehow its terms are known by the time you're twelve.

The eldest child in a Malaysian family inherits something that doesn't get listed in any legal document, a set of expectations assembled gradually, through inference and example, until they become simply what is required of you. You are expected to lead by example. You are expected to not need too much attention, because attention is a resource and there are other children who need more of it. You are expected to understand before you are old enough to fully understand.

And when the family hits difficulty, financial, medical, logistical, you are, by default, the one who stands at the front of it.

This is not cruelty. It comes from real practical necessity in families where resources are stretched and every person who can contribute, should. The eldest is usually the first one capable, which makes them the first one called. By the time the younger siblings are old enough to help, the eldest has already been carrying for years and the pattern is set.

A researcher who spent time studying Malaysian family dynamics wrote that in lower-income households, the role of the eldest child often overlaps significantly with what in other contexts would be considered a co-parent, managing younger siblings, translating adult information to family, serving as a buffer between stressed parents and an uncertain world. This is not uncommon. It has just never been named as a thing that might leave a mark.

What you give up is less obvious than what you gain. The eldest often achieves more, academically and professionally, partly from the responsibility, partly from necessity. But they also arrive at adulthood with a complicated relationship to their own needs. Wanting things for yourself can feel greedy when you've spent formative years aware of what other people in the house need. Resting can feel like abandoning a post.

There's a particular loneliness to it that the younger siblings don't always register. The eldest was figuring things out first, without a model, often pretending to more confidence than they had because someone needed to. The younger ones had a pathfinder. The eldest made the path.

This isn't a complaint on behalf of eldest children. Many carry what they carried with pride, and some of what they built through carrying it is real. The competence is real. The resilience is real.

But so is the cost of never quite having been just a child, unencumbered, let to figure yourself out before being handed someone else's needs to figure out first.

The contract was never signed. It was just understood. And like most things we never choose but simply absorb, it takes years to see it clearly enough to decide what to do with it.

Some people carry it forward without question. Some spend half their adult lives untangling what they actually want from what they were told was needed of them.

Both are understandable. Neither is wrong.